5 Questions to Choose a Fixed or Variable Annuity Before You Sign
Fixed annuities offer a guaranteed minimum return set by the insurer; variable annuities put your money into investment subaccounts, so payments rise and fall with the market, according to Investor. If you want predictable lifetime income, a fixed annuity is the more direct fit. If you can tolerate market swings and higher costs in exchange for growth potential, a variable annuity fits better, though the SEC recommends reading the full prospectus before either purchase.
TL;DR:
Fixed annuities guarantee a minimum interest rate and are suitable for short- to medium-term goals, while variable annuities expose your investments to market fluctuations with higher fees.
Variable annuities typically have total annual expenses between 1.3% and 2.2%, and surrender periods can extend beyond eight years, limiting liquidity during the early years.
Income riders can provide guaranteed lifetime income but come with added fees, and fixed annuities are more predictable with straightforward payout calculations.
Inflation erodes the real value of fixed annuity payments over time, whereas variable annuities with market exposure have better long-term growth potential, though without guaranteed protection.
Always review the contract’s detailed fee schedule, surrender rules, and insurer’s financial strength before signing, as high fees and poor contract terms disproportionately affect outcomes.
Table of Contents
Fixed vs variable annuities at a glance
The two products solve different problems, and the gap shows up most clearly in five areas.
Guarantees: Fixed annuities lock in a minimum interest rate for the contract term; variable annuities guarantee nothing on the investment portion, only what optional riders add.
Upside and downside: Fixed contracts cap your gains at the stated rate; variable contracts let you capture full market upside and full market downside in the subaccounts you choose.
Fee profile: Fixed annuities typically build costs into the crediting rate; variable annuities layer separate charges on top of your account value.
Liquidity: Both types restrict withdrawals during a surrender period, though the length and penalty schedule vary by carrier and contract.
Complexity: Fixed annuities are simpler to evaluate; variable annuities require reading a prospectus and understanding subaccount performance.
Fixed indexed annuities sit in between: they credit interest linked to a market index but still guarantee a floor, so they are not identical to variable annuities even though both involve market exposure.
A typical variable annuity carries a base mortality-and-expense charge of about 1.25%, and total annual expenses can run roughly 1.3% to 2.2%, once administrative and fund costs are added, per SEC and FINRA guidance. That range determines how much of your account’s growth actually reaches you.
How fixed annuities work, including MYGA and indexed versions
A fixed deferred annuity credits interest at a rate the insurer sets, subject to a guaranteed minimum interest rate stated in the contract. Even if the insurer’s current rate drops after your initial term, the guaranteed minimum is the floor you’re contractually owed.
Multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGA) lock a fixed rate for a set number of years, which makes them a fit for short-to-medium horizons where you want a bond-like return without market exposure.
Fixed indexed annuities (FIAs) credit interest based on an index’s performance, subject to caps, spreads, or participation rates, with a 0% floor that prevents a loss from market declines. That crediting method differs fundamentally from a variable annuity, where your account value can actually fall.
Before signing, confirm the guaranteed minimum rate, how the rate renews after the initial term, and the length of the free-look period, all points the NAIC’s buyer’s guide recommends checking.
A market value adjustment clause in some fixed contracts can also swing your surrender value by hundreds of dollars on a $100,000 balance if you withdraw early, so ask whether your contract includes one.
Pro Tip: Ask for the guaranteed minimum rate in writing, separate from the advertised “current” rate, since only the guaranteed figure is contractually locked.
How variable annuities work and what the prospectus reveals
A variable annuity allocates your premium into subaccounts, essentially mutual-fund-like portfolios, so your account value moves with the underlying investments daily. Some variable contracts also include a fixed account option, letting you split money between guaranteed and market-linked buckets.
Mortality and expense charge: Often around 1.25% annually, per the SEC.
Administrative fees: Cover recordkeeping and contract servicing.
Underlying fund expenses: Charged by the subaccounts themselves, similar to mutual fund expense ratios.
Rider fees: Added separately if you elect income or death-benefit guarantees.
Total annual expenses on a variable annuity commonly run 1.3% to 2.2%, according to SEC and FINRA estimates, a meaningful drag when compounded over a retirement horizon. Contracts can also carry different share classes with different fee and surrender structures, which is exactly why the prospectus matters: it spells out every charge and the surrender schedule in one document. Before buying, request the prospectus and the plain-English summary, and don’t sign until you understand each fee line.
What fees, surrender rules, and taxes mean for your income plan
Both fixed and variable annuities restrict access to your money during a surrender period, and the penalty structure can differ sharply by carrier.
Surrender periods can run eight years or longer on some variable contracts, per FINRA.
Penalty-free withdrawals are often capped around 10% annually, though the exact allowance varies by contract.
Larger withdrawals during the surrender period typically trigger a charge and can also cancel future rider benefits.
Surrender charges and limited withdrawal allowances mean an annuity is not a source of quick, penalty-free cash in the first several years, a point FINRA emphasizes for both product types.
On taxes, nonqualified annuity withdrawals come out earnings-first and are taxed as ordinary income on that portion; withdrawals before age 59½ generally trigger an additional 10% federal tax unless an exception applies, per IRS Publication 575. Qualified annuities, held inside an IRA or similar account, follow different withdrawal and required-minimum-distribution rules. If you’re weighing an exchange into a new contract, treat it carefully: exchanges can restart the surrender clock and strip existing benefits.
A five-question checklist to decide which annuity fits you
Work through these questions in order before choosing a product.
What is your time horizon? Shorter horizons favor a MYGA; longer ones give a variable annuity more time to recover from downturns.
Do you need guaranteed lifetime income now or later? A strong income need points toward a fixed annuity or a rider-backed lifetime withdrawal benefit.
How much loss can you tolerate? If a market drop would derail your retirement plan, a fixed or fixed indexed annuity limits that exposure.
How much fee drag can your plan absorb? Every percentage point in fees compounds against you over decades.
Do you have legacy or beneficiary goals? Some contracts offer death-benefit riders worth comparing against simpler beneficiary designations.
Buyer profile one: A 68-year-old retiree prioritizing steady income tends to fit a fixed annuity or annuitization over a rider-heavy variable contract. Buyer profile two: A 55-year-old still accumulating assets with a decade before retirement may accept variable annuity volatility for growth potential.
FINRA’s suitability standards require weighing time horizon, liquidity needs, and risk tolerance before any recommendation, and an exchange is often inappropriate if it merely restarts a surrender period for a marginal rate improvement.
Pro Tip: If you cannot answer all five questions confidently, that’s a sign to get a second opinion before signing anything.
What to request before you sign anything
Before committing to either product, request five documents: the prospectus, the fee schedule, rider pricing details, the surrender schedule, and the insurer’s financial-strength rating. Missing any one of these makes it difficult to judge what you’re actually buying.
Some independent agencies work with business owners and individuals evaluating fixed and fixed indexed annuities as part of broader retirement income strategies, with tradeoffs often involving guaranteed income versus liquidity and fees. Clients seeking more control over capital while building long-term value sometimes explore Infinite Banking concept strategies involving whole life insurance as alternatives or complements to annuity purchases, depending on cash flow and goals.
Read the contract before you read the brochure. The brochure sells the current rate; the contract defines what you’re actually guaranteed.
— Jib Hunt
How market swings affect a variable annuity’s value
Because variable annuity subaccounts hold market-linked investments, your account value can drop in the same year the broader market falls, unlike a fixed annuity’s guaranteed floor. That volatility flows directly into any future income calculation: if you plan to annuitize or draw an income rider based on account value, a downturn right before that decision can shrink your payout base.
Some variable contracts soften this with a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit that locks in an income base regardless of market performance, but that guarantee usually comes at the cost of an added rider fee. Without such a rider, a sustained downturn in the years just before or after you start withdrawals can permanently reduce the income the contract supports, since withdrawals during a down market lock in losses that a later recovery cannot fully reverse. This sequence-of-returns risk is one of the clearest arguments for pairing a variable annuity with either a rider or a separate guaranteed-income source, so a single bad market year doesn’t dictate your entire retirement income.
Understanding income riders and lifetime withdrawal guarantees
An income rider, often called a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit, lets you take a defined percentage of a protected income base each year for life, even if the underlying account value falls to zero. The income base is typically separate from your actual account value: it may grow at a stated rate during years you don’t withdraw, but it usually cannot be cashed out as a lump sum.
These riders add an annual fee on top of the annuity’s other charges, so the guarantee has a real cost that reduces net returns in years the market performs well. They matter most for people who want market participation but cannot risk running out of income if markets underperform during their withdrawal years. Fixed and fixed indexed annuities can carry similar riders, though the starting point differs since the base contract already guarantees a minimum credited rate. Before adding a rider to any contract, compare its annual cost against simply annuitizing a portion of your account for guaranteed income, since the rider isn’t always the cheaper path to the same outcome.
Comparing payout options between the two annuity types
Both fixed and variable annuities offer similar payout structures once you decide to convert the contract into income, but how that income is calculated differs. A fixed annuity’s payout is based on a known account value and a set of insurer payout rates, so you can calculate the monthly income before committing to a payout option like life-only, period-certain, or joint-and-survivor.
A variable annuity’s payout, when taken through annuitization rather than a rider, can either be fixed once elected or can continue to vary with subaccount performance depending on the contract, which makes the future payment amount harder to predict in advance. If the contract includes a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit instead of full annuitization, the payout is set against the protected income base rather than the fluctuating account value, giving you a more predictable number without permanently converting the contract. Whichever option you consider, the payout choice is generally irrevocable once elected, so compare life-only against joint-and-survivor and period-certain options carefully against your actual life expectancy and beneficiary needs before signing.
Why inflation matters for annuity purchasing power
A fixed annuity’s guaranteed rate is set in nominal dollars, so if inflation runs higher than expected over your contract term, the real purchasing power of your guaranteed income erodes even though the dollar amount stays the same. This is one of the more overlooked risks in a fixed annuity, since the guarantee protects against market loss but not against inflation eating into what that guaranteed check actually buys.
A variable annuity’s market exposure gives it a better chance of keeping pace with inflation over long horizons, since equity subaccounts have historically had more growth potential than a fixed rate, though there’s no guarantee any given year’s return will match or beat inflation. Some contracts offer a cost-of-living adjustment rider on income payments, which raises the payout over time but adds another fee layer. Whichever type you choose, factor inflation into your income plan explicitly: a level payment that looks sufficient today may fall short a decade or two into retirement.
The tradeoff nobody sells you on the brochure
The industry pitch for variable annuities leans on growth potential, and the pitch for fixed annuities leans on safety, but both pitches skip the part that actually determines your outcome: the contract language. A guaranteed minimum rate that renews poorly after year one, or a rider fee that quietly erodes a variable contract’s returns matters more than which category you picked.
Conventional advice tends to frame this as a binary choice, growth or safety, when the more useful framing is sequencing. Someone a decade from retirement can afford variable annuity volatility that someone drawing income next year cannot. The mistake we see most often isn’t choosing the wrong type, it’s skipping the prospectus or buyer’s guide and trusting a rate sheet instead. Read the actual contract, ask what happens after the introductory rate ends, and check the insurer’s financial strength before you check the return.
— Jib Hunt
This article is general information, not a substitute for advice from a qualified financial advisor. Consult a qualified financial professional about your own circumstances before acting on anything here.
Sources
FAQ
What does Warren Buffett say about fixed annuities?
There is no verified, sourced statement from Warren Buffett specifically addressing fixed annuities available in the sources reviewed for this article. General guidance from Investor.gov recommends comparing an annuity’s guarantees and fees against your actual retirement-income needs rather than relying on any single commentator’s opinion.
How much does a $500,000 fixed annuity pay per month?
Monthly payout depends on the insurer’s current payout rates, your age, and the payout option chosen, such as life-only or joint-and-survivor, so no single figure applies universally. Request an illustration directly from the carrier using the guaranteed minimum rate, as recommended by Investor.gov, to see an actual projected payment.
What does Dave Ramsey say about variable annuities?
Sourced material for this article does not include a specific, quotable statement from Dave Ramsey on variable annuities. Regardless of any commentator’s view, the SEC advises reading the full prospectus and understanding all fee layers before purchasing one.
What is the downside of a variable annuity?
The main downsides are market risk to your account value and a higher fee load, with total annual expenses commonly running 1.3% to 2.2%, according to SEC and FINRA estimates. Surrender periods can also run eight years or longer, limiting access to your funds without penalty during that window.
Where can I get personalized guidance on choosing between annuity types?
East Two West works with individuals and business owners to compare fixed, fixed indexed, and other retirement-income strategies against your specific cash flow and goals. You can review available options and request a consultation to see which approach fits your situation.
Recommended
Comments